Tuesday, December 5, 2017

Pupcakes – the main ingredient is imagination!

Pin It

When my sister said “Cake Sale... Next Saturday... For charity... Inspiration for the novice baker please?!”, it had to be Pupcakes.

These are my (current) favourites. They are a little fiddly to make but so worth it when you see the reaction they get. Both kids and grownups deliberate for ages over their choice. When I point out that each of these little cuties tastes the same, I often get the reply “But, Hester! They all have different personalities! I have to find the one that’s right for me!”

For 1 dozen cute pupcakes (each with their own personality) you will need...
... a small star-shaped piping nozzle such as a Wilton 22 and a piping bag (or a freezer bag with the corner snipped off to accommodate the piping nozzle).
1 dozen vanilla-flavoured plain cupcakes

Buttercream Icing
250g butter (not dairy spread), at room temperature (i.e. soft)
275g icing sugar, sifted
½ teaspoon vanilla extract

1.                 Place the soft butter together with half the icing sugar in a large mixing bowl or stand mixer. Mix together slowly to avoid filling the kitchen with a sweet sugar cloud. When mixed, add the second half of the icing sugar and the vanilla essence and whip until light and fluffy – I usually mix this in my stand mixer, leaving it running for 5 minutes. This amount will decorate 12 cupcakes.

To decorate the pupcakes you will need...
6 red/pink Starburst sweets (or similar soft fruit caramels), for the tongue
6 marshmallows for the muzzle, snipped in half so you have two discs from each
a further 4 marshmallows for the ears, each snipped into 4 long slices then rolled out to make long floppy ear shapes
24 Smarties (or similar sweets) for the eyes (pairs of matching colours if possible)
12 Smarties (or similar) for the nose - pink or brown look good

a little imagination 
Mmmmm, I feel like a kid in a candy store!

2.                 First, make the tongues: Unwrap 1 Starburst (or soft fruit caramel) and place it in the microwave for about 4 seconds to soften it slightly. Roll it out to a thickness of about 2mm. Using a kitchen scissors, cut out rounded teardrop shapes about the size of your index fingernail. You should get 2 tongues from each sweet. Fold each teardrop gently in half, then unfold to create a line down the centre of the tongue. Gently bend to make natural-looking tongue shapes (as shown in the photo above). Ok, that was the difficult bit. The rest is an easy assembly job.
3.                 Next, If your cupcakes are domed, cut the tops off in line with the top of the cupcake cases to make a level surface for your icing.
4.                 Half-fill your piping bag with the freshly-whipped icing (piping bags are a lot easier to work with if not too full).
5.                 Cup a cake in one hand and, with the other, pipe icing all over the surface using little stabbing motions to mimic the appearance of fur.  It doesn’t have to be too neat.
6.                 Place a marshmallow half – with the sticky, cut side, down - off-centre to create the muzzle. Cover this with icing too. Place 2 Smartie eyes on the cake as shown in the photo below. Top the muzzle with another Smartie for the nose.
7.                 Press a pair of marshmallow ears either side of the eyes, making sure a sticky side is in contact with the icing as this helps it adhere.
8.                 Insert a Starburst tongue between the muzzle and the cupcake to secure.
9.                 Finally, pipe a cute little curl just over the eyes. Once you’ve done one, the rest are much quicker to assemble. Store in a cool dry place (not the fridge!)
Start with a level base; use half a marshmallow for the muzzle; add marshmallow ears
and candy eyes and nose; finally poke the tongue just under the base of the muzzle. 

The event, at St Matthias Hall in Killiney, Co. Dublin on Saturday, December 1st, 12 noon to 2pm, is in aid of the Intellectual Disability Association of Lesotho. Christmas music... mulled wine... tea, coffee, hot chocolate with marshmallows...  mince pies.... cakes, buns, cupcakes etc. as well as some Christmas crafts... Break Christmas in gently...

Come along on Saturday and meet the Ambassador of Lesotho and his family as you deliver a delicious donation, or simply take time out to enjoy one of the gorgeous creations on offer along with a cuppa and maybe even get some of your Christmas shopping done.

And, hey! Hands off! That one's mine!

Other bake sale ideas include:

Honey, Lemon and Almond Tartlets - this recipe makes 18
Banana, Pear and Coconut Loaf - excellent with coffee, improves if made ahead of time

If you have your own favourite bake sale recipe that you’d like to share with the bakers participating in the sale, please email me your link at simpleingredientsmagicalfood@gmail.com, and I’d be delighted to add it to the list. Pin It


  1. Hester, now that I have looked at your adorable "Pupcakes" whith two of my girls looking over my shoulder, I know what I will be doing on the weekend...mine will not look remotely as adorable as yours though. What a thoughtful idea to bake these absolutely adorable "Pupcakes" for a charitable cause!

  2. Awwwwww these are one of the cutest cupcake designs in the history of cupcake designs :)

    Choc Chip Uru

  3. These are just so good, who could resist. These would definitely stand out on any cake stall.

  4. Hester, these are absolutely wonderful - my favourite part is the tongue hanging out! I haven't heard of starburst sweets so need to find them. I adore your imagination as ever. Wishing you a great bake sale at the weekend!

  5. Hi Jill, thanks for your lovely comments. Starburst are what Chewits used to be.

  6. This is the cutest post I've seen in ages. I cannot wait to try these. LOL I'll definitely do my best!

  7. Oh my gosh - how cute are these cupcakes! You are truly a jack of all trades. You cook, bake and decorate. I'm impressed. :)

  8. OMG! Hester, this is amazing! I'm blown away with the idea of using Starburst sweets for ears and tongues. Absolutely cute and these would sell FAST!!!

  9. Hester these are just too cute! I love your imagination:)

  10. That's got to be the first blog on the internet ever to include the delightful phrase - 'First make the tongues'!

    Makes for a nice twist on that famous 18th century culinary phrase 'First, catch your hare'. I prefer your tongue phrase though. Hester - much tastier!!

  11. Hi Sarah, thanks for pointing out the unwitting paraphrasing of Hannah Glasse! Unfortunately these 'hares' met a quick end. I am counting on the baker who requested the inspiration to produce the goods tomorrow! :)

  12. Girl, i bet you raised the most money with these GADORABLE pupcakes. I'd have bought a dozen myself!

  13. Oh my word! This is the cutest thing I've seen all week Hester!

  14. I love that these are called pupcakes! They look so cute.

  15. Ohhhh.... these are adorable and very creative!

  16. SO darn cute!!! I'm sure they'll be a hit at the bake sale!!!

  17. Oh my gosh these are freaking adorable. I love these pupcakes.

  18. Hester...these are INCREDIBLE! Well I don't consider myself a novice baker...I DO consider myself a novice decorator and so I appreciate your step by step instructions on decorating these! You are sooo clever and creative! : )


Share your thoughts - I'd love to hear from you!